AA1After Delta Air Lines announced miles would be based on ticket price instead of distance flown back in February 2014, and five months later United essentially copied and pasted their mileage program, every travel and points expert predicted that American Airlines (AA) would follow suit. AA was the last major holdout and though we all figured they would go to the dark side, we hoped they wouldn’t. The biggest question surrounding it was when would it happen since they were still working on completing their merger with US Airways.

In November 2015, American sent out a press release touting their new changes and “its award-winning AAdvantage loyalty program.” The only reason it was award-winning is because they didn’t follow Delta and United so that title was quickly lost.

American didn’t give a specific date when the changes to earning award miles would take effect, only that it would be in the second half of 2016. Today, they made it official: August 1, 2016 will be doomsday for the majority of their AAdvantage members. American also came out with some unexpected and unpleasant surprises for those who buy cheap tickets, fly long distances and don’t have elite status.

Earning award miles
For travel beginning August 1, 2016, flights marketed by American will earn award miles based on the price of the ticket purchased. Elite members will earn more miles based on their status level.

Elite Status Level AAdvantage member Gold Platinum Executive Platinum
Miles earned per USD spent 5 7

(40% bonus)


(60% bonus)


(120% bonus)

base fare plus carrier-imposed fees, excluding any government-imposed taxes and fees

Keep in mind that AA states, “award miles for travel on most flights marketed by partner airlines will be based on a percentage of the flight distance and the booking code purchased.”

They also warn that beginning later this month, customers will be able to see an estimate of the number of miles and elite-qualifying credits they will earn for a chosen itinerary when booking their trip on aa.com.”

As my buddy Zach Honig from The Points Guy points out, “Of course, this new structure most benefits AA customers who book expensive tickets. For example, say you’ve booked a round-trip flight from New York to Los Angeles for $340. Of that, $300 counts as the “base fare,” which is used to calculate earnings. Currently that fare doesn’t factor in at all when it comes to the number of redeemable miles awarded—for an economy ticket, you’ll earn roughly 5,000 miles as a base member and 10,000 miles as a top-tier elite. Under the new structure, however, base members would earn 1,500 miles ($300 x 5) and Executive Platinum members will earn 3,300 miles—far less than they would have before.”

New elite qualification requirement
American’s new elite qualification requirement was the biggest shock since they previously said they weren’t going to follow Delta and United in this regard. Another reason never to believe the airlines. Come January 1, 2017, Elite Qualifying Dollars (EQD) will be added to the elite-qualification requirements. Below is the amount needed to earn elite status. Members will need to spend a certain amount and either qualify with usual Elite Qualifying Miles (EQM) or Elite Qualifying Segments (EQS). The EQD goes from $3,000 for Gold to $12,000 for Executive Platinum.

Gold Platinum Platinum Pro Executive Platinum
25k EQMs


30 EQSs

50k EQMs


60 EQSs

75k EQMs


90 EQSs

100k EQMs


120 EQSs

$3k EQDs $6k EQDs $9k EQDs $12k EQDs

New elite level
Starting January 1, 2017, the AAdvantage program will add a fourth elite level called Platinum Pro. This is for members who fly between 75,000 miles and 99,999. Benefits will include:

  • Complimentary auto-requested upgrades on all eligible flights within North America and between the U.S. and Central America
  • Earn nine award miles/U.S. dollar (80% bonus)
  • Two free checked bags
  • oneworld Sapphire status


Changes to upgrade benefits
Sometime in 2017, AAdvantage members will see changes to how upgrade requests are prioritized along with a new benefit for Executive Platinum members:

  • Upgrade priority will be based on a 12-month rolling EQD total, sorted by elite status level. That means if two Executive Platinum members are traveling and bought their tickets at the same time, the one who spent the most in the past 12 months will get higher priority.
  • The best news out of their announcement is that Executive Platinum members will be able to use their complimentary 500-mile upgrade benefits on AAdvantage award tickets for travel on American from Main Cabin to the next class. Though you can’t upgrade from Business Class award tickets to First Class.


Bottom line:
This is obviously terrible news for those who buy cheap tickets, fly long distances and don’t have elite status. It’s good news for those road warriors who fly up front, buy full-fare tickets and fly between 75,000-99,999.


9 Comments On "American Airlines Drops the Hammer on Its Soon-to-Be-Former Award-Winning Mileage Program"
  1. Christina|

    I wish I hated traveling. :(

  2. JustTheFacts|

    Parker is transforming American into US Air, which came from parasitic mergers with the likes of Cal, Air Worst, Piedmont, and too many more to mention.. If I am a stock holder (never again airlines, my learner Eastern) I have no qualms. As long as American has their monopoly markets like Delta and United, the seats will continue to be filled. Maybe customers will start to consider value rather than miles when ticketing. People vote with their feet, but unfortunately if there is no choice, feet don’t count.

  3. frank|

    i think they also increased the required mileage for a business class flight between the US and thailand or philippines (maybe all parts of Asia) from 120000 to 140000 miles. Horrible.

    1. Johnny Jet|
  4. JJ|

    What does the AA “downgrade” do for those of us who have accumulated miles? Will those miles depreciate or be grandfathered in until they’re used?

    1. Johnny Jet|

      The mileage awards always lose value which is why you should never hold on to them all for too long. I keep enough in case there’s an emergency and need to buy a last min ticket.

  5. Roger Dean|

    Dear JJet,

    All the other airlines have watered down their FF programs, so is this really news(or a surprise)?

    What’s most funny is that YOU will likely have to travel coach more often and pay for upgrades (like the 95%+ of flyers), so perhaps your future newsletters will reflect what air travel is really like.
    Your experiences in the air have been warped beyond reality, as you fly business/first often and also get free hotel stays, trips, perks because you’ve sold yourself by hawking credit card companies, airlines, hotels, etc.
    Johnny, welcome to the our world. Get used to it!

    1. Johnny Jet|

      Ha! I only promote cards that are valuable to readers.

  6. ed|

    I just booked the rest of my AA miles for Kauai for Jan, 2017.
    I will cancel my AA credit card before next year’s charge hits.

Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *

Recent posts